A Look at the Penguins’ Most Memorable Player Nicknames

This retrospective examines some of the most creative nicknames given to Pittsburgh Penguins players over the franchise’s history. It groups the names by origin, including labels from teammates or reporters, self-chosen handles, and fan-selected nicknames. Examples include Beau Bennett’s “Sunshine,” Paul Bissonnette’s “BizNasty,” and Mario Lemieux’s “Super Mario.”
The piece traces Pittsburgh nicknames across nearly six decades, sorting them into three buckets: names from teammates or reporters, names players chose themselves, and names fans popularized. It lists examples such as Sidney Crosby’s “Darryl,” Matt Cullen’s “Dad,” Mario Lemieux’s several handles, and Brooks Orpik’s “Free Candy.”
It also explains a few origins: Beau Bennett’s “Sunshine” tied to his California roots and a film character; Paul Bissonnette’s “BizNasty” grew from his AHL days and on-ice chirping; Nick Bjugstad’s “Rotisserie Chicken” came from a missed dinner and a grocery-store meal, later inspiring Florida fan stunts.
This retrospective may resonate with Penguins fans and hockey-history readers by preserving informal team lore. It could help newer supporters connect with past players through memorable stories, while media figures and former players may see their nicknames reinforced. Such nickname lists may also shape fan culture, merchandise, and online discussion, though their broader societal effect is likely limited to sports communities.